John Payne

Clay Fletcher

Gail Russell

Susan Jeffers

Sterling Hayden

Bert Donner

George 'Gabby' Hayes

Pesky Tees

Dick Foran

Sheriff La Farge

Eduardo Noriega

Don Nacho Vázquez

Henry Hull

Henry Jeffers

Mary Beth Hughes

Stagecoach Nellie

H.B. Warner

Judge Fletcher

Robert Ellis

Jack Elkins

Catherine Craig

Mrs. Elkins

Arthur Space

John Elkins

Steven Geray

Mexican Joe

Irving Bacon

Stage Passenger (uncredited)

Argentina Brunetti

Don Nacho's Woman (uncredited)

Jack Perrin

Barfly (uncredited)

Denver Pyle

Vigilante (uncredited)

Dan White

Henchman (uncredited)

Nacho Galindo

John Hart

Herbert Heywood

Reed Howes

Peggy McIntyre

Lorin Raker

Pierre Watkin

Lee 'Lasses' White

Gloria Winters

Chief Yowlachie